Sennadar Forums

Here's a question: do we as a forum have an official constitution with bylaws, or a procedural manual, and if we don't, should we draft one? Imean that way we could have a legal contract that identifies our various sects, groups, and cults, and the purpose of each of these groups here within this forum? What do you guys think? I'm more than willing to do it, with a little help, of course!

I think you have to much time on your hands to think up something like that for this forum.

Saelamin wrote:I think you have to much time on your hands to think up something like that for this forum.

I really do...hence the post...

Halcyon wrote:Here's a question: do we as a forum have an official constitution with bylaws, or a procedural manual, and if we don't, should we draft one? Imean that way we could have a legal contract that identifies our various sects, groups, and cults, and the purpose of each of these groups here within this forum? What do you guys think? I'm more than willing to do it, with a little help, of course!

I think that because of the electronic signiture act we should be very careful about what sort of artifice facade documents you want to create and be bound to. Personally, I think that is a very bad thing for this group, and especially for Fel and Spec. So I in no way would support this. Thats my counsel...

~Michael

Constitutions suck we have enough laws in real life without bringing them into the Internet.

Long live Anarchy!

michaelsuave wrote:I think that because of the electronic signiture act we should be very careful about what sort of artifice facade documents you want to create and be bound to. Personally, I think that is a very bad thing for this group, and especially for Fel and Spec. So I in no way would support this.

I'm not bound by US law - yes, the forum is hosted in the US, but I can move it outside US Jurisdiction, if I wanted to.

In any case - bylaws etc sound way too formal, and I'm not interested in administering it. It's hard enough ensuring any moderation I do isn't unfair or heavy handed, and is as transparent as I can make it.

Edit: An appropriate QOTD on my Google Homepage:
The United States is a nation of laws: badly written and randomly enforced.
- Frank Zappa

Spec8472 wrote:In any case - bylaws etc sound way too formal, and I'm not interested in administering it.

Okay, maybe I shouldn't post straight after waking up... But uhm - basicly I mean that I think the <a href="http://sennadar.plebian.net/forum/viewt ... =62">Forum Guidelines</a> should bee enough, really.

I think the two guiding principles "Common sense applies, most of the time." and "If you wouldn't say it infront of your mother/brother/sister/children, think twice before posting it here." should cover most of it -- there's some more stuff below that, if people really want to clarify that.

Creating a Charter, with By-Laws, a Constitution, and a whole sort of pseudo-legal framework is creating a whole lot of work for someone, which will probably be either unenforcable - or create so much of a headache for anyone trying to moderate a discussion, that it'll discourage all parties (moderators, users, etc)

I think the short answer here is just no. The long answer I think is just use common sense. If you don't mind people seeing what you say, say it. If you do, don't--within the Forum Guidelines of course.

Darn... too much laws will make it unconstitutional to go Off-Topic.

Mizriath wrote:Darn... too much laws will make it unconstitutional to go Off-Topic.

That's unlikely to stop some.

Spec8472 wrote:

Mizriath wrote:Darn... too much laws will make it unconstitutional to go Off-Topic.

That's unlikely to stop some.

Well, I wasn't entirely serious about the whole drafting a constitution thing, I mostly wanted to see how people would respond.

Spec8472 wrote:

Mizriath wrote:Darn... too much laws will make it unconstitutional to go Off-Topic.

That's unlikely to stop some.

Hey, I resemble that remark!